As Pai Mei, the famous kung-fu
master, trains The Bride (Uma Thurman) in martial arts high atop an oriental
mountain pass in Kill Bill: Volume 2,
finding any relevance of the South in Tarantino’s works seems doubtful, but
look no further than Kill Bill (both
volumes) and Pulp Fiction to find
Southern stereotypes at their best. In Kill
Bill, The Bride (Uma Thurman) seeks revenge on her former assassination
squad for the murder of her unborn daughter. Bill, the squad leader, assists in
crashing her wedding rehearsal while putting a bullet in her head that sends
her into a four-year coma. Upon waking years later, The Bride succeeds in
hunting down all four members of her squad, but not without difficulty. In the
end, The Bride finds Bill and the daughter she once thought she lost forever.
Unflinchingly, The Bride never strays from her path of revenge and kills Bill.
Two
characters shape the entire image of Southern culture within Tarantino’s Kill Bill: the hillbilly trucker and Budd.
While the Bride lays in a coma, a male nurse, Buck, sells her body for sex to,
no other than, a hillbilly trucker. Similar to Deliverance, the Southern male is portrayed on a level more evil
than monster. In this instance, rape in order to show dominance cannot be the
case since the Bride is in an unconscious state – she cannot resist. Here, the
rape of a woman who is unable to defend herself is an outrage. On the other
hand, Kill Bill: Volume 2, presents
the dimwitted Southern hick, Budd (Michael Madsen). Budd is first seen telling
Bill that he pawned his priceless samurai sword for $250. The entire
conversation takes place at Budd’s trailer while he sips on a liquor bottle. Ignorant
fool, drunkard, and trailer trash are all Southern stereotypes that fit Budd.
He goes on to talk very harshly and perversely about The Bride while she lies
on the ground bleeding out from the shotgun shells he put in her chest. Finally,
Budd is taken advantage of in a business trade with Elle Driver (Daryl Hannah).
The cowboy is an easy target because his peers view him as ignorant and
dimwitted.
An
earlier film by Tarantino, Pulp Fiction,
also has one of the most powerful scenes that portray the South in negative ways
that followed, again, in Deliverance’s
footsteps. The film contains multiple stories; however, the main Southern
stereotype comes with the conflict of Butch and Marsellus. A washed-up boxer, Butch
(Bruce Willis) is chased through the city streets by Marsellus Wallace (Ving
Rhames) after Butch’s refusal to throw a fight breaks a business deal between
the two. Both end up in a fistfight on the floor of Maynard’s pawnshop, where
Maynard proceeds to tie them up at gunpoint before calling his hillbilly
friend, Zed. The two are taken down to the basement where Butch is left with
“The Gimp” – a man chained up in a full-body leather suit - while Marsellus is taken into the next room
and raped by Zed.
Marsellus’s
race is imperative in this scene. Tarantino portrays the Southerns as monsters
who are consumed with such hatred that they rape a black man who comes across
their path. Apart from John Boorman’s wild canoe trip, Pulp Fiction’s hillbilly monsters take advantage of criminals, which
allows the audience to sympathize with criminals over Southerners. People who
view this outside of the South see films like Deliverance and Pulp Fiction
and, undoubtably, would never want to be left alone with a Southern man. Meanwhile,
during the majority of the rape scene, the camera is held upon Butch and the
dangling “Gimp,” who works as a symbol of the mask put up by the South to cover
up their dark, sadistic desires. The hillbillies serve as a contrast or foil to
the once rivals, Butch and Marsellus, who overcome their mutual differences in
order to unite against the greatest enemy of all - the Confederate hillbilly
(rebel flag is dawned in his pawnshop) and redneck sherrif.
Regardless
of which film is viewed, Pulp Fiction
or Kill Bill, Southern men serve the
purpose of glorifying every other character they interact with. They are the
antithesis of good and honest men. The Southern monsters unite black and white
no matter what their differences because these men rape black men, take
advantage of those who are defenseless, racially disgrace those who are
different, and are ignorant drunks as depicted in modern films such as Pulp Fiction and Kill Bill. Regardless of the situation, Southern pride is set
against all other entities represented in these films. The South is more than “backwards”
in Pulp Fiction and Kill Bill; it is inhumane to the utmost.
-
Brandon Landis
I have never seen these shows and I think I am going to keep it that way. From what you described the south really is portrayed in a very negative light. Yes, the south has unspeakable qualities. However, so does the north. People in general, regardless of where they live have unspeakable qualities. I guess what I am trying to say is wow.
ReplyDeleteAt first, I was a little skeptical about finding the "southern" in either film, and, now, after watching Deliverance, I have to agree that the rape scene in Pulp Fiction does give off the impression of a violent Southern male. Quite frankly, who would want to be left alone with something like that? I love how Brandon pointed out all the negative characters- the hillibilly, the Sheriff,and Zed- to further depict the negative connotations that are often associated with the South. Also, after reading some of the basic plot of Kill Bill, I'll probably be watching it in the next few days.
ReplyDeleteI think it's fairly interesting, and a little bit grim, that two of the factors connecting the Southern elements in these movies revolve around rape. Regardless of the gender differences in these two scenarios, the one question in my mind about the whole ordeal is this: Would these scenes have happened and been scrutinized the same way without Deliverance's prevailing image and message in our minds? I think it's kind of mind-blowing how much power that one scene has over Southern stereotypes in general.
ReplyDeleteI've seen all of these movies, but I never really thought about how Tarantino's movies portrayed Southerners. The rape scene in Pulp Fiction is just a devastating and repulsive as the one in Deliverance and does nothing to help the image of Southerners. The overwhelming majority of people who live in the South are not even remotely like this. However, these images persist in popular culture. This images will never let the South move past its occasionally dark and storied past and into the future. Deliverance and Pulp Fiction create such a vivid and pervasive image that even years after the release of these movies all a person has to do is hum a few bars of a tune and sodomy performed by backwoods hicks is brought to mind. If these stereotypes are continued to be set forth for public consumption they will continue to live on.
ReplyDeleteI have seen both of these movies multiple times as well, and I have not viewed them as portrayals of Southern behavior before this moment. I think Brandon makes some awesome points and has done some great analysis. I also want to expound on Michael's questioning of the impact of Deliverance. Since viewing the movie in class, I have seen one other movie with a rape scene. Instantly, I compared the scene to that of deliverance and tried to draw a message from it. The movie had no traces of Southernness, but I tried to make the correlation exist anyway. Awesome stuff Brandon.
ReplyDelete